I've been enjoying it a lot! I like that the plots are about forgeries and schemes (not so much killing!), and the relationship are interesting. I really like the kind of emotional straight-forwardness of the show. Sure, they hide things from each other, but they also are very expressive in terms of their admiration, respect and affection for each other--Neal and Peter, of course, but also Peter and Elizabeth (Neal and Elizabeth!), Peter and his team (and yes, thrilled Diana's back--I really like her relationship with Peter--and now with Neal). You can see why the (porny) fanfic is such a lovefest. Maybe I was just in the mood for a show that wasn't so angsty ;).

ps: I have ordered Carnivale, S1!